top of page

Is It Time to Replace Your Water Heater? Understanding the Signs

Deciding whether to replace your water heater requires a comprehensive understanding of its lifespan and the subtle signs of aging. While tankless water heaters boast a remarkable lifespan of 20 years or more, traditional models with standing water tanks tend to exhibit signs of wear and tear after approximately 10 to 15 years.

Types of Water Heaters

It's essential to distinguish between the two primary types available in water heaters. Traditional water heaters store heated water in a large tank, ensuring a constant hot water supply throughout the day. On the contrary, tankless water heaters heat water on demand, delivering instant hot water without needing a standing tank.

Tankless water heaters' longevity and maintenance requirements often surpass those of their traditional counterparts. Identifying your specific type of water heater is crucial when evaluating its lifespan and contemplating a potential replacement.

Signs Your Water Heater Might Fail

Several indicators suggest that your water heater is on the verge of failure. While age is a significant factor, other signs warrant attention:

Strange Noises

Unusual sounds emanating from your water heater, such as popping or cracking, may indicate sediment buildup. This sediment can solidify at the bottom of the tank, causing the heater to work harder to produce the same amount of hot water and potentially inflating your utility bills. Regular professional maintenance, including annual tank draining, can mitigate sediment issues. However, if sediment has already solidified, replacement may be necessary to prevent cracks and leaks.

Colored Water

Dirty water containing sandy or rusty debris clearly indicates a failing water heater. Once water is contaminated, replacement becomes an imminent necessity.

Changes in Water Temperature

A noticeable change in your water temperature is another red flag that your water heater is faltering. Issues with the gas burner, electric coil, or sediment buildup can disrupt reliable hot water production. If you cannot achieve the desired water temperature or experience inconsistent temperatures, it could indicate that replacement is imminent.

Visible Damage

The presence of visible rust or cracks in your water heater is cause for concern and may necessitate repairs or replacement. While professionals can sometimes repair these issues, an older water heater may require replacement, even if repairs are feasible. For instance, a 20-year-old water heater is likely nearing the end of its service life, making replacement a more prudent option.


Leaks in your water heater are a severe symptom that demands immediate attention and replacement. A buildup of pressure inside the tank often causes leaks, indicating a malfunctioning relief valve or potential issues with anxiety or temperature. Regardless of the specific cause, leaks signal an urgent need for a new water heating system.

Benefits of Proactive Water Heater Replacement

The decision to replace your water heater before it fails comes with various advantages:

Time for Research

Proactively replacing your water heater provides ample time for thorough research. Both tankless and traditional water heaters have a long lifespan, meaning it may have been a while since your last replacement. By acting preemptively, you can explore various options, such as traditional or tankless models, and consider different variables to select the water heater that best suits your home's efficiency and performance demands.

Prevent Further Damage

Addressing potential issues before they escalate prevents further damage to your home. While a small leak may not seem alarming initially, it can lead to flooding if left unattended. Water leaks typically indicate widespread failure of the entire unit, rendering repairs impractical. If ignored, leaks can escalate, potentially causing the tank to burst and extensive flooding within your home.

Avoid Emergency Replacements

While extending the life of your water heater is desirable, relying on a faulty or aging unit may lead to an emergency replacement. A failing water heater can cease functioning suddenly, leaving you in a challenging situation. Emergency replacements often come with added stress and higher costs. By opting for proactive replacement, you can schedule installation at your convenience, eliminating the need to go without hot water. This approach provides peace of mind, as you can trust your new water heater to meet your daily hot water needs reliably.

Save Money

Replacing your water heater before it fails can save costs in several ways. Firstly, a new water heater will likely be more energy-efficient, especially if you opt for a tankless model. The energy efficiency of tankless water heaters often exceeds that of traditional models, translating to lower utility bills. Additionally, avoiding constant repairs on an aging unit contributes to long-term cost-effectiveness. As a water heater ages, its maintenance and repair needs increase, leading to cumulative costs. By choosing to replace the unit, you benefit from improved efficiency and avoid the ongoing expenses associated with maintaining an older system.

Water Heater Replacement in Denver

If you need a water heater replacement near Denver, look no further than the trusted professionals at Daniel & Donna Plumbing Services. Serving the region since 1990, our experienced team possesses the skills and knowledge to recommend the perfect water heater for your home and ensure a seamless installation process. Whether you have concerns about a 15-year-old water heater or general questions about replacement, we are ready to provide the expertise needed to keep your home running smoothly. Contact us today for reliable water heater services tailored to your specific requirements.

Recent Posts

See All

How to Choose a Plumber Near You

1. Reviews don't lie, when looking for a plumber near you always do your research and read what other real customers have said. 2. What hours are they available? Check hours to see if a plumber fits i


bottom of page